The wine industry is in trouble. Yes, it’s a rollercoaster; what goes up must come down and vice versa. But right now, we are sitting in the lull. We are all strapped into that fiberglass shell of a seat, listening to the agonizing clink-clink-clink of the chain lift working to get us to the top of the first hill. Each inch of movement is a back-and-forth grind, making it feel like an eternity to get to the peak, while the sheer anticipation of what happens next fills us with dread.
Just when we think the tracks are looping into a total nose-dive thanks to the WHO and the Surgeon General shouting in 2023 that ‘no amount of alcohol is safe,’ a new study drops and yanks the coaster in the exact opposite direction. Enter the Journal of General Internal Medicine, basically telling us to hold our glasses, because, shocker, moderate drinking might not be the death sentence they claimed it was. Seriously, can they make up their bleeping minds?!”
Science is supposed to be analytical and peer evaluated, but this rubberband opinion on the health benefits/harm of alcohol causes consumer whiplash. What is more frustrating is that our society only remembers the bad things. Why? Because fear sells. A headline that reads ‘That Nightly Glass of Wine Might Be Killing You’ gets millions of clicks, shares, and morning talk-show segments. It panics people, and panic drives engagement. But a headline that says ‘Hey, Guess What? Moderate Wine Consumption is Actually Perfectly Fine and Fits into a Holistic, Healthy Lifestyle?’ Boring! It doesn’t trigger the algorithm. So, the terrifying warnings get permanently etched into the public consciousness, while the scientific corrections get buried on a back page no one reads. It leads to a culture of fear over a culture of facts.
Case in point: a new study in the Journal of General Internal Medicine by well-respected cancer researcher Laura C. Pinheiro, PhD, titled, “Re-evaluating the Alcohol-Cancer Link: Long Term Cancer Mortality Outcomes.” Dr. Pinheiro and her team did what the sensationalist headline-grabbers failed to do: they looked at the data through a realistic, human lens. They evaluated alcohol consumption within a holistic lifestyle context, actually accounting for variables like diet, smoking status, physical activity, and socioeconomic status.
And guess what the data actually showed? Things that are, or at least should be, common sense.
First, heavy drinking is associated with higher cancer mortality. Is this a surprise to anyone? Moderation has been the flag for the wine industry for generations. In fact, moderation is the key to almost everything in life. Take sunshine, for example. It’s excellent for you. When ultraviolet B (UVB) rays strike your skin, your body produces Vitamin D, which improves bone health, muscle function, cardiovascular health, and mood regulation. But too much sun causes painful sunburns, premature aging, and compromises the immune system. Over time, excess exposure damages cell DNA and significantly increases the risk of skin cancer.
On the flip side of the spectrum, the study showed that light drinking actually correlates with lower cancer mortality, while moderate drinking showed absolutely no association to cancer mortality. Read that again: moderate wine drinking didn’t change the risk at all.
If you dig deeper into how these anti-alcohol scare campaigns get their numbers, you realize the deck is stacked from the start. They love to compare moderate drinkers to people who consume zero alcohol. But statistically, you can’t just treat a “zero alcohol” group as a perfect baseline. It’s inherently biased.
Why? Because it completely ignores why those people aren’t drinking. Many abstainers don’t drink because they already have underlying health conditions, are on medications, or are recovering from past health issues. When researchers lump all non-drinkers together without accounting for their socioeconomic status, diet, or overall health, the data gets completely warped. They end up making moderate drinking look dangerous simply because they compared it to a flawed baseline. Dr. Pinheiro’s study finally cleaned up the data, looked at the whole human picture, and proved that common sense was right all along.
The study’s final conclusion is the only one that we need to remember before reading the next click-bait article: “We encourage cancer prevention strategies to step away from isolating single health behaviors and consider holistic perspectives of an individual’s lifestyle including physical activity, smoking, diet, and alcohol consumption.”
So, let’s step off the health-headline rollercoaster for just a second and take a deep breath. The next time a scary, click-bait notification pops up on your phone telling you that your favorite beverage is public enemy number one, remember the facts. Remember that health isn’t built on a single, isolated choice, but on the whole, beautiful, messy picture of how we live our lives. Science will undoubtedly continue to bounce around, and the media will keep trying to trigger the algorithm with panic. But as for me? I’m going to stick to common sense, a healthy lifestyle, and a perfectly moderate glass of wine (or two). How about you?
~Slàinte!
I invite you to follow me on Instagram, Twitter, Facebook Threads and Youtube for all things wine. I’ll never tell you what to drink, but I’ll always share what’s in my glass. Please subscribe to my blog by entering your email address under “Subscribe to Blog by Email” in the right hand column.
Ready to turn your passion into expertise? Whether you’re looking for foundational classes like Wine 101, Sparkling, and Rosé, or you’re ready for a deep dive into specific regions, we have a digital course or class for you! For those specifically interested in Spain, don’t miss our fun Exploring Spanish Wine: The Bingo Brains Edition or our professional-level Uncork Rioja Certification. Explore our full range of educational classes and find your next wine adventure: View All Wine Education Options.
We’ve stacked the odds so that you can get our award winning wines without breaking the bank. Click the image to find out all of the benefits of joining the CHALK CLUB including discounted shipping and up to 25% off all purchases. .
